April 23Apr 23 comment_531956 Hi all,I’m currently looking at a retrofit project for a commercial site that wants to ditch their old Wiegand readers for something more secure—ideally OSDP v2 to meet their new IT insurance requirements.The headache is the existing cabling. It’s mostly unshielded, and as we know, OSDP over long runs can be finicky without proper twisted pairs. I’m trying to avoid a full re-wire if possible, but I'm worried about the data integrity for their higher-security zones.Has anyone here had success using OSDP converters on legacy cables for high-stakes areas? Or is it always a case of "pull new copper or don't bother" when it comes to meeting modern audit standards?Would love to hear some field experience on where you draw the line between 'secure enough' and a total infrastructure overhaul. Security System Integrator | Networking & IP Camera Specialist Currently lab-testing / deploying: CIVINTEC RFID & OSDP Access Control solutions. Link to comment https://www.thesecurityinstaller.co.uk/community/topic/47500-legacy-upgrades-the-struggle-of-retrofitting-osdp-on-existing-wiegand-infrastructure-without-a-full-re-wire/ Share on other sites Share on LinkedIn Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share via email Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
April 23Apr 23 comment_531960 Yeh you got to be careful due to data. Its a big risk but always recommend to recable if the cable isnt twisted pair or screened Link to comment https://www.thesecurityinstaller.co.uk/community/topic/47500-legacy-upgrades-the-struggle-of-retrofitting-osdp-on-existing-wiegand-infrastructure-without-a-full-re-wire/#findComment-531960 Share on other sites Share on LinkedIn Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share via email Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
April 24Apr 24 Author comment_531963 17 hours ago, shabir said:Yeh you got to be careful due to data. Its a big risk but always recommend to recable if the cable isnt twisted pair or screenedCompletely agree on the risk, @shabir Data integrity is the non-negotiable part here. The dilemma is always the cost/time of a full re-cable vs. the client's push for immediate 'compliance'.I’ve been looking into some OSDP transparent converters that claim to handle the encryption at the end-points specifically to mitigate the noise issues on older non-twisted pairs. It seems like a potential middle ground for sites where the physical infrastructure is just too painful to rip out, but the audit trail still needs to be AES-128.Have you ever found a specific converter or a signal conditioning setup that actually held up in an audit without a full re-wire, or is the consensus in the field still 'new copper or bust' for high-security zones? Security System Integrator | Networking & IP Camera Specialist Currently lab-testing / deploying: CIVINTEC RFID & OSDP Access Control solutions. Link to comment https://www.thesecurityinstaller.co.uk/community/topic/47500-legacy-upgrades-the-struggle-of-retrofitting-osdp-on-existing-wiegand-infrastructure-without-a-full-re-wire/#findComment-531963 Share on other sites Share on LinkedIn Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share via email Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
April 24Apr 24 comment_531964 I've never heard of it nor been asked about it securitywarehouse Security Supplies from Security Warehouse Trade Members please contact us for your TSI vetted trade discount. Link to comment https://www.thesecurityinstaller.co.uk/community/topic/47500-legacy-upgrades-the-struggle-of-retrofitting-osdp-on-existing-wiegand-infrastructure-without-a-full-re-wire/#findComment-531964 Share on other sites Share on LinkedIn Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share via email Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
Create an account or sign in to comment