Jump to content
Security Installer Community

Hour Rate Or Point System?


marx

Recommended Posts

Hi,

What would u prefer hour rate or point system! few years ago i worked in company where they had point system. So one pir=1 point, bellbox=2, internal camera=2, alarm panel (depends how big) 2-4points, 100m cable=1point. And u know what engineer worked hard to get good points end of the month! But when u have hour rate u will take your time to finish the job lol. I think if u have point system u have different attiude, u will do the job correctly and if u have to then work few hours late to finish the job! But with hour rate what is the change that some one will work late, they will most likely say that they will have to come back tomorrow to finish the job lol. Point system will motivate engineer more then hour rate. I can see point system working well only on smaller sites becose on big sites u might have to pull cables for few weeks. Or mabe the perfect solution would be to use bouth hour rate and point system to keep everybody happy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

or employ someone with honest work ethics and sack the slackers?

dragging your heels is wrong.

what is it there shouting for on TV....oh yeah honest days pay for an honest days work.

do the honest days work 1st I say!

viva la revolution!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The first National I worked for had a thing called budget costing that was only used on domestics.

Basically you got 7 hours to wire the job, fit the controls and external sounder.

You then got 1 hour for each PIR and half hour for each contact, digi was a bonus because you got 4 hours for that.

It worked well for the engineer on a small job in a bungalow but you were under pressure in an occupied house.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest old-hand
The first National I worked for had a thing called budget costing that was only used on domestics.

Basically you got 7 hours to wire the job, fit the controls and external sounder.

You then got 1 hour for each PIR and half hour for each contact, digi was a bonus because you got 4 hours for that.

It worked well for the engineer on a small job in a bungalow but you were under pressure in an occupied house.

1Hr a Pir, 30n mins a fMC....................4 hrs a Digi...........................Gis a job!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

problem with any point or system size based system is that the faster you put it in the more points you earn. Ultimatly quality suffers as your encouraging speed. There is a limit to how much you can do in a set time and do it right.

Using hourly systems shouldnt encourage engineers to put it in quick at the expense of quality.

securitywarehouse Security Supplies from Security Warehouse

Trade Members please contact us for your TSI vetted trade discount.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The first National I worked for had a thing called budget costing that was only used on domestics.

Basically you got 7 hours to wire the job, fit the controls and external sounder.

You then got 1 hour for each PIR and half hour for each contact, digi was a bonus because you got 4 hours for that.

It worked well for the engineer on a small job in a bungalow but you were under pressure in an occupied house.

under pressure?

semi 4 pirs and 1 contact. = 11 1/2 hours lol and 4 hrs for the DIGI :lol: i wish i had time like that when i was cards in, they expected 8 zones in 8 hours.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest old-hand
under pressure?

semi 4 pirs and 1 contact. = 11 1/2 hours lol and 4 hrs for the DIGI :lol: i wish i had time like that when i was cards in, they expected 8 zones in 8 hours.

"Thinks back" 12 Redcares in same street 4 hours, must admit all we sent then was 2,3,4,and 7.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I cant see how anyone no matter how good can correctly install 8 zones in 8 hours on a domestic

We give 3.4 hours for the panel, and 1.7 hours per device (is sab, pir, etc) average domestic is 2 man days well is for us

securitywarehouse Security Supplies from Security Warehouse

Trade Members please contact us for your TSI vetted trade discount.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest old-hand
I cant see how anyone no matter how good can correctly install 8 zones in 8 hours on a domestic

We give 3.4 hours for the panel, and 1.7 hours per device (is sab, pir, etc) average domestic is 2 man days well is for us

With respect, you must employ monkeys who can only scratch their //.B.W.F.// all day.

Not being funny here at all, almost 4 hours to dress and prog a panel??????????

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With respect, you must employ monkeys who can only scratch their //.B.W.F.// all day.

Not being funny here at all, almost 4 hours to dress and prog a panel??????????

Not at all. All of our guys are very good. Agreed not the fastest but i dont want fast and poor, i want them well installed. Thats why we allow the time we do.

securitywarehouse Security Supplies from Security Warehouse

Trade Members please contact us for your TSI vetted trade discount.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

under pressure?

semi 4 pirs and 1 contact. = 11 1/2 hours lol and 4 hrs for the DIGI :lol: i wish i had time like that when i was cards in, they expected 8 zones in 8 hours.

Yes but when I worked to this scheme it was the early 80s in rural Lincolnshire.

We were an NSCIA company and rarely did small domestics, they were all bloody great farm houses and PIRs cost a fortune in those days, it was contacts on all doors and maybe 1 or 2 PIRs.

The scheme was really put in place to help surveyors cost the job because otherwise they would go in too cheap to compete against the local cowboys!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest old-hand
Not at all. All of our guys are very good. Agreed not the fastest but i dont want fast and poor, i want them well installed. Thats why we allow the time we do.

Average inspection marks ?

Grommets used?

Only asking, b4 ya leap....x

PS, customers from previous incarnation`s praise me for programming their alarm/access systems to suit their needs rather than the basic set ups "most" fools think and cannot get their heads around.

That is why you do UDL and set up from office James, and not trust them.

EDIT

Fools as in not understanding systems. Obviously the regulations are adhered to!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

What would u prefer hour rate or point system! few years ago i worked in company where they had point system. So one pir=1 point, bellbox=2, internal camera=2, alarm panel (depends how big) 2-4points, 100m cable=1point. And u know what engineer worked hard to get good points end of the month! But when u have hour rate u will take your time to finish the job lol. I think if u have point system u have different attiude, u will do the job correctly and if u have to then work few hours late to finish the job! But with hour rate what is the change that some one will work late, they will most likely say that they will have to come back tomorrow to finish the job lol. Point system will motivate engineer more then hour rate. I can see point system working well only on smaller sites becose on big sites u might have to pull cables for few weeks. Or mabe the perfect solution would be to use bouth hour rate and point system to keep everybody happy.

Well, I guess we're talking engineer motivation here.

I'm not a fan of anything that encourages corner cutting, and I think most "performance" schemes do that, to be honest. The idea is for the company to motivate the engineers to produce just a little more - profit - essentially. They do that, most often, by cutting corners, it seems, rather than emphasising quality.

The only productivity scheme I've come across that I think works, is one in which installation engineers are targetted on least number of warranty call backs per new system. That is, they install the system, no call backs for six months after (some reasons excluded) they get the bonus. Similarly for service engineers, first time fix rate - above 95% (other than non stock parts) for six months, bonus paid.

Generally, I've found that if you pay engineers a fair wage, and ask for fair work, you get it, and I've also found that engineers don't like to go back in their own time to fix faults of their own making. They tend to get it right after doing that once or twice.

Lots of other things can help morale and motivation though - like not handing over systems on a Friday.....like making sure correct job kit is issued, like ensuring the spec is accurate, and the salesman/surveyor is accountable in some way if "design" is wrong - or the designer if certificated design.

Again, I've only ever found a points sysem useful for calculating things like fire alarm maintenance.

Bill.

Bill

Accord Fire & Security Services Ltd.

www.accordfire.co.uk ~ TEL: 0845 474 5839

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I cant see how anyone no matter how good can correctly install 8 zones in 8 hours on a domestic

We give 3.4 hours for the panel, and 1.7 hours per device (is sab, pir, etc) average domestic is 2 man days well is for us

It can be done, i installed loads all were spot on, but its not how we do it, as IMO i had towork to hard. We give 2 men 1 day.

All my jobs were spot on, but when i went on to 90% service/fault they got someone else doing them and they couldn't do them in less then 12hrs, and they were rough TBH.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

post removed

Often, that's true.

Just another industry gripe - the whole salesmen/no technical experience thing.

Salesmen, like engineers, tend to get better the harder their wallets are hit.

I don't think either that asking our industry to carry out risk assessments is especially fair, or clever - most of us are technically biased - not risk biased.

I still believe, as I did when the whole notion of graded systems was first mooted, that the insurance companbies should get off their fat, very well paid, arses and do their own risk assessment, grading their cover properly, and then the level of protection THEY think is needed. The cost arguement is then between the insurer and his customer, and we get a clear shot at installing systems which have been assessed as required by a third party, and so do not have to carry the risk of wrongful advice (at least as far as grading goes).

Two chances of that ever happening - so, in the interim, the only real choice is to push your people to do better - to perform better RAs, to sell accurately, to install well, to maintain well, and to keep your customer base. Sometimes, taking money back out of their pockets reminds them to do a little better. Mostly, having everyone pull in the same direction reminds them to do a lot better.

Just another reason why we're about to see a big swing back to much smaller cmpanies than we've been used to these last many years.

Bill.

Bill

Accord Fire & Security Services Ltd.

www.accordfire.co.uk ~ TEL: 0845 474 5839

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I cant see how anyone no matter how good can correctly install 8 zones in 8 hours on a domestic

We give 3.4 hours for the panel, and 1.7 hours per device (is sab, pir, etc) average domestic is 2 man days well is for us

On them times I'd like to work for you

Manchester based Lee 07709 736 987

www.secure-solutions.info

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes but when I worked to this scheme it was the early 80s in rural Lincolnshire.

We were an NSCIA company and rarely did small domestics, they were all bloody great farm houses and PIRs cost a fortune in those days, it was contacts on all doors and maybe 1 or 2 PIRs.

Wow - and Noah still sailed in his ark too! See, that was when an ark was a boat, an arc was part of a circle, and you sent your signals to a central station!!!

How things change.

Those one or two PIRS both went on the "part set" circuit, and the rest went on the main zone, I'm betting too.....ah the days. Nothing wrong wit hthe good ol' BS80, or the upgrade - the BS80/2.....

The scheme was really put in place to help surveyors cost the job because otherwise they would go in too cheap to compete against the local cowboys!

Now, there's the thing - most "points" schemes I've come across were purely service pricing indicators, and most "timings" were there for pricing. Simple rule was, you took a quarter off the surveyor's time and told the engineer or subbie that was what was in the job - e.g. surveyor prices 16 hours, you tell the lads 12. It was a hard business in those days......

But, after all of that, and two and a half decades of sightseeing in this fine vocation of ours, I'm more convinced than ever that the only system that works consistently is one which encourages quality, rather than kwality, skill, rather than skil, and pride rather than ego. No, I haven't found it yet either, but working on it.

Bill.

Bill

Accord Fire & Security Services Ltd.

www.accordfire.co.uk ~ TEL: 0845 474 5839

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.